89 Finlay Street
Stone Mills, ON
2 bed • 3 bath • approx. 2000-2500 sqft • Detached • 51 days on market
Step into a truly one-of-a-kind home-this beautifully converted 1875 church in Strathcona blends historic character with modern comfort. Featuring soaring ceilings and an abundance of natural light, this property offers a warm and inviting atmosphere throughout. The main living space boasts an open-concept design with a spacious living and dining area, perfect for entertaining or relaxing. The home includes 1 bedroom, 1.5 baths, and convenient main-floor laundry. The chef-inspired kitchen is a standout, complete with a large island and an adjoining prep area offering ample cabinetry and counter space. Just off the kitchen, a charming screened-in porch provides the perfect spot to enjoy your morning coffee and take in the sunrise. Upstairs, a versatile loft-style family room overlooks the main living area, showcasing the home's unique architecture. This flexible space can easily be converted into an additional bedroom if desired. The property also features a private in-law suite with its own separate entrance. This self-contained space includes a spacious living room with a natural gas fireplace, a newer kitchen, a bedroom, full bath with walk-in shower, and its own laundry. A cozy 3-season sitting area adds even more comfort and privacy. Outside, enjoy peaceful surroundings from your deck. A detached, heated 2-car garage with plenty of natural light and a paved driveway adds convenience and functionality. Located just a short walk from the K&P Trail, this exceptional property offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of history with modern versatility. Be sure to ask for the full list of updates-this home truly does not disappoint.
Virtual Tour
Virtual Tour Available
Listing Details
- Taxes (2025)
- $3,164
- Listed
- July 7, 2026
Price History
Listing history
Sign in to view
Property
- Style
- 2-Storey
- Age
- 100+
- Construction
- Stone
- Roof
- Asphalt Rolled, Metal
- Foundation
- Stone
- Interior
- Auto Garage Door Remote, Carpet Free, In-Law Suite, Primary Bedroom - Main Floor, Solar Tube, Water Heater Owned, Water Softener, Water Treatment
- Lot Size
- 138.64 x 131.93 Feet
Utilities
- Water
- Drilled Well
- Sewer
- Septic
- Heat Source
- Gas
Location & Legal
- Cross Street
- County Road 16
- Zoning
- HR
- Parcel Number
- 451160450
- Possession
- Flexible
Commercial
- Occupancy
- Owner
Included
- Inclusions
- 2x Fridge, 2x Stove, 2x Washer, 2x Dryer, Hot Water Tank, Furnace, A/C, Hot Water on Demand for the in law suite (located in garage), All Attached Light fixtures, Bathroom Mirrors (except the 1 listed in exclusions), All Window Coverings. Water Softener, 4Barstools
- Exclusions
- Bathroom Mirror above sink in Primary bedroom (on main floor)
Schools
Elementary
- Newburgh Public School3.1 km
Public · Limestone DSB · 140 students
Grade 3 reading: 76% met the provincial standard · Grade 6 math: 45% met the provincial standard
Straight-line distance. Nearby schools are not necessarily the assigned schools — confirm catchment with the school board. Scores are EQAO provincial test results for 2024-2025.
Community
Postal area K7R
- Population
- 15,480
- Private dwellings
- 6,845
- Median age
- 50.4
- Average household size
- 2.3
- Median household income
- $77,000
Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census of Population, catalogue 98-401-X2021013. Adapted from Statistics Canada. This does not constitute an endorsement by Statistics Canada of this product.
Local market
Residential Freehold in Stone Mills · last 12 months
- Median sold price
- $525,000
- Homes sold
- 105
- Median days on market
- 37
- Sale-to-list price
- 96.4%
Based on 105 recorded sales of residential freehold properties in Stone Mills over the last 12 months.
Rooms
2-piece on Main, 3-piece on Main, 3-piece on Second
Upper
- Bathroom4' x 5'4"
- Bedroom9'7" x 13'4"
- Family Room25'11" x 16'1"
- Kitchen7'4" x 16'8"
- Living Room9'11" x 19'
Main
- Bathroom8'8" x 8'3"
- Foyer7'1" x 6'11"
- Kitchen26' x 12'6"
- Laundry10'2" x 6'5"
- Living Room15' x 26'1"
- Primary Bedroom10'2" x 12'7"
Listed by
RE/MAX FINEST REALTY INC., BROKERAGE
Location
Mortgage Calculator
$165,400
Estimated Monthly Payment
$4,063
Investment Analysis
No recent nearby lease data. Enter a rent to see the numbers.
Mortgage: $4,063/mo (20% down, 5.5%)
Taxes: $264/mo · Insurance: $207/mo
Estimates only. Consult a financial advisor.
Reita | Assistant
Online
Reita is an automated assistant, not a licensed real estate agent. I can help you explore neighbourhoods, understand the market, and find our free tools. What are you looking for?